Skip to Content

I requested a distribution of $20,000 from my retirement account and elected to have 7% withheld for federal tax.

Last Updated April 5, 2009

Question: 

I requested a distribution of $20,000 from my retirement account and elected to have 7% withheld for federal tax. However, the custodian withheld 10% without my permission and informed me that they are required withhold 10%. Is that true?

Answer: 

It depends. Distributions from your retirement account are subject to withholding rules. However, the withholding rules that apply depends on if the distribution represents a periodic payment or a non-periodic payment. Additionally, the payer may be required to apply certain withholding if the distribution is made from a qualified plan , 403(b), or 457(b) plan. For this purpose, periodic payments are defined as payments from a pension plan that are spread out over more than one year (periodic payments). Non-periodic payments are ad-hoc one-time distributions or distributions paid within one-year.

For periodic payments from a pension or annuity, the withholding amount is calculated using the same method that is used to determine withholding salaries and wages, and the you would simply instruct the payer on how much to withhold.

For non-periodic payments, the following applies:

  • If the distribution is made from an IRA, the amount withheld for federal tax must be zero, 10% or more than 10%. As such, your IRA custodian did the right thing.

  • If the distribution was made from a Roth IRA, withholding applies only to the taxable portion of the distribution, and the traditional IRA rules(above) would apply. However, a custodian may be unable to ascertain how much of a Roth IRA distribution is taxable.

  • If the account is a qualified plan , 403(b) or 457(b) plan, the following withholding rules apply:

    • If the amount is rollover eligible and is processed as a direct rollover to an eligible retirement plan, no withholding applies

    • If the amount is rollover eligible and is paid to you , the payer is required to withhold at least 20% for federal taxes

    • If the amount is not rollover eligible, the minimum withholding amount is 10%, unless you elect zero withholding.

 

The payer may also perform State tax withholding in addition to any federal tax withholding. Special rules apply to amounts that are sent overseas. These are explained in IRS Publication 515, available at www.irs.gov