Skip to Content

Bad-Boy Clause

Last Updated March 21, 2009


A provision in a qualified plan, under which a participant would lose – usually unvested- benefits, if the participant engages in dishonest activity such as fraud, that involves the plan assets.

Referring Cite

Temp. Treas. Reg. §1.411(a)-4T, Revenue Ruling 85-31

Additional Helpful Information

  • Bay boy clauses are not always enforceable
  • The plan must usually define the circumstances under which benefits would be forfeited, before the circumstances occur. Otherwise, it may not be enforceable
  • Bad boy clauses cannot include time restrictions on vesting that goes beyond the vesting schedule. For instance, if the clause is non-competing in nature, it cannot provide that if the participant leaves to work for a competitor after the vesting period expires, the benefits would be forfeited